27 Comments
User's avatar
Beth Kephart's avatar

From one multi genre person to another. Keep going.

Expand full comment
Claire Polders's avatar

Thank you, Beth! โค๏ธ

Expand full comment
Barbara Krasner's avatar

I used to think I lacked focus, because I wrote fiction, nonfiction, and poetry for adults and kids. I determined a year ago that I didn't, in fact, lack focus. I was just a multi-genre author. Thanks for the validation!

Expand full comment
Claire Polders's avatar

I fear there our many of us multi-genre writers out there feeling secretly ashamed instead of versatile. Letโ€™s change that!

Expand full comment
Roberta McKay's avatar

Hmmm - you sound like me except with crafts and art. I crochet, have done quilting, play the guitar, dance, sew, journal, sing, knitting, scrapbooking.

Expand full comment
Claire Polders's avatar

You're a versatile artist! When others enjoy and explore multiple arts, I am often in awe. When I diversify, I blame myself for not being focused. Perhaps I wrote this post to be kinder to myself.

Expand full comment
Doc's avatar

Your versatility and ability to adapt to whatโ€™s needed is a gift! It seems to be more valued in creative people than in the business world, though I think there are exceptions. It reminds me of a true Renaissance person, Leonardo da Vinci, who was painter, sculptor, draughtsman, engineer, scientist, theorist, and architect. If you look at a fraction of his notebooks you can see how wide-ranging his interests were: anatomy, botany, cartography, astronomyโ€ฆwhy not? Itโ€™s a pretty incredible world and thereโ€™s no reason to limit yourself, especially when youโ€™ve found a demand for what you do.

One of the things that drew me to your posts was the varied subjects - I think the first was about your grandmother. I love following your travels with your husband and the adventures you have - your photos next to the huge lizards were amazing, and the video of the donkeys trotting through your yard was sheer delight. Thank you, for not putting yourself and your gifts into a limited box. Enjoy! Your readers sure do. ๐Ÿ˜„

Expand full comment
Claire Polders's avatar

Thank you so much, Doc. Comments like yours truly help me to embrace what I do and keep going with it. Limited boxes be gone!

Expand full comment
Michael Jensen's avatar

It's fascinating to see where the road takes us, isn't it? Mine is pretty similar as yours!

Expand full comment
Claire Polders's avatar

Yes, fascinating indeed!

Expand full comment
Jeanine Kitchel's avatar

I think it's great that you stretch -- to different styles, genres, art forms. In essence, too, it's survival.

Expand full comment
Claire Polders's avatar

You're right, it's survival, too. Perhaps that's why I feel this shame, this weight of failure: My diversification was never a pre-planned choice.

Expand full comment
Jeanine Kitchel's avatar

Diversification imho is a skill, learned through testing out a wide variety of, well, everything that appealed or was needed to make it in life. Plus it makes that person, you, more interesting bc youโ€™ve explored the smorgasbord we call life.

Expand full comment
Claire Polders's avatar

Thank you! Thatโ€™s a great approach to this subject!

Expand full comment
Pam Reese's avatar

You are not dabbling. My husband was in higher education at the start of his career and wrote academic paper and plays and has a wonderful novel about the Vietnam War which never found an agent- wait I think he found one agent who couldnโ€™t sell it. He left academia and took to writing plays, one of which was performed in Atlanta GA. Now retired we began cowriting cozy mystery stories based on our time in Lafayette Louisiana where I was getting my PHD. He sent the first one to a cozy mystery publisher who had her publishing house in Aurora IL, a suburb of Chicago. Once we got in the rhythm we cowrote 13 cozy mysteries set in a coastal community in Mississippi on the Gulf Coast and had a lot of fun going to mystery writers conferences. Our publisher just retired but if you are curious used copies can be found for sale on Amazon, put there by readers who donโ€™t hold on to every book, like I tend to do. This all happened after we were bare nesters over a decade. I guess I shared our story here to encourage you to write what the muse tells you to write. In Chicago now, retired, as I am a spousal caregiver for my writing partner with Parkinsonโ€™s Disease, I have found myself writing poetry like crazy about our Parkinsonโ€™s life together. Thatโ€™s why I joined SubStack- to share my poetry, though I havenโ€™t had the time (or the nerve) to post them yet. I guess this is a long post to say keep writing!!!

Expand full comment
Claire Polders's avatar

Thank you so much for sharing your story! It has the encouraging effect you intended. And I hope you will start sharing your poems soon. I remember writing a lot of short snippets, prose poems maybe, when my mother was ill with Alzheimer's.

Expand full comment
All Over The World's avatar

Oh, this sounds like something I'm constantly facing, and battling! I'm a generalist as well, except I'm interested in different forms of creativity - writing (of course!), making art, beading, gardening, reading, cooking, traveling, sigh!

Expand full comment
Claire Polders's avatar

Is it something to battle, though? To me you sound like a versatile creative person.

Expand full comment
All Over The World's avatar

Thank you for saying that, Claire! The old adage, โ€˜Jack/Jill of all trades, master of noneโ€™ is usually on repeat mode in my brain.

Expand full comment
Carina Grasbeck's avatar

A Jill of all trades and master of none has been my trade mark since childhood. My lovely boss once told me she considers me multitalented. That's what I try to remember when I like you feel I need to niche myself and then find it impossible.

We are curious and creative beings!

Expand full comment
Claire Polders's avatar

Itโ€™s interesting how we can see someone else active in multiple areas as multi-talented and ourselves as a Jill of all trades. Letโ€™s change that and grant ourselves that same generosity.

Expand full comment
Carina Grasbeck's avatar

You are absolutely right!

Expand full comment
Robin Flicker's avatar

Iโ€™m so glad that you write in various genres; you are large, you contain multitudes. So happy to see the quotation from Merleau-Ponty.

Expand full comment
Claire Polders's avatar

Thank you, Robin! So happy that our recent conversation reminded me of how much I love Merleau-Ponty!

Expand full comment
Robin Flicker's avatar

Iโ€™m happy about that too Xx

Expand full comment
Kate Webb's avatar

Being consistently varied is the best kind of brand, I think! Itโ€™s so easy to conflate โ€œconsistencyโ€ with โ€œsameness.โ€ Sameness is boring. Consistent variety is delightfulโ€”in a lifestyle and in a newsletter!

Expand full comment
Claire Polders's avatar

I love how you phrase that: consistent variety!

Expand full comment